Wildy Logo
(020) 7242 5778

Book of the Month

Cover of Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments

Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments

Price: £470.00

Family Court Practice


Wildy, Simmonds & Hill

Just Published

The Complete List...

Offers for Newly Called Barristers & Students

Special Discounts for Newly Called & Students

Read More ...

Secondhand & Out of Print

Browse Secondhand Online


Credit Card Processing Problems

Thu 6th May - We are currently experiencing issues with our credit card processing resulting in delays to order confirmations being sent. We hope to have the issue resolved shortly and apologise for any inconvenience caused

Hide this message

Biotechnology, Patents and Morality: A Deliberative and Participatory Paradigm for Reform

ISBN13: 9780367181246
Publisher: Routledge
Country of Publication: UK
Format: Hardback
Price: £115.00

This is a Print On Demand Title.
The publisher will print a copy to fulfill your order. Books can take between 1 to 3 weeks. Looseleaf titles between 1 to 2 weeks.

Also available as

This book critiques the decision-making process in Article 53(a) of the European Patent Convention. To date, such decisions have been taken at high levels of expertise without much public involvement. The book eschews traditional solutions, such as those found within legislative, judicial and patent office realms and instead develops a radical blueprint for how these decisions can be put to the public. By examining wide-scale models of participatory democracy and deliberation, this book fills a significant gap in the literature. It will be invaluable for patent lawyers, academics, practitioners and intellectual property and patent officials.

Intellectual Property Law
General Introduction
Brief introduction to the European patent system
The emergency of morality and its inclusion in European patent law
A tripartite nexus: biotech comes of age, patents proliferate and morality matures
Outstanding disquiet: who gets to decide and how?
A participatory paradigm for deliberative decisions
Chapter One: In Search of a Definition of Morality in European Patent Law
1.1 Introduction
1.1.2 Origins of patent law and its evolution until present times
1.1.3 Patent requirements
1.2 National to International Coverage: changes in protection in both form and substance
1.2.1 The Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property 1883
1.2.2 Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948
1.2.3 Strasbourg Convention 1963 – an optional morality provision
1.2.4 Patent Cooperation Treaty 1970
1.2.5 European Patent Convention 1973 - morality mandated Patentable and non-patentable inventions, morality and other exemptions in the EPC Filing and oppositions Appeal procedures
1.2.6 Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) 1994
1.2.7 Directive 98/44/EC on the legal protection of biotechnological inventions
1.2.8 Amendment to EPC 2000
1.2.9 Patent Law Treaty 2000
1.2.10 An EU-wide patent Precursors Unitary Patent Protection
1.3 European case law on morality and ordre public
1.3.1 At the EPO
1.3.2 The drafting intentions of the EPC Morality: universal abhorrence (plants) Morality: balancing test (animals) Morality: morality sidelined? Morality: risk of harm – polls and survey evidence Morality: universal outrage Morality – a case of doctrinal confusion? Morality parameters: narrowing or broadening? Morality and human embryos: a more restrictive approach? Arbitration of morality: who should be responsible? Morality beyond WARF at the EPO Ordre public: the EPO’s new morality?
1.3.3 Morality in the case law of the CJEU Commentary
1.3.4 Conclusion
Chapter Two: Patent Moralities and Their Traditional Adjudications - A Critique
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Untangling morality of the invention and morality in patent grants
2.2.1 Can morality provisions in patent law just be ignored?
2.2.2 Opposition on morality grounds: public voices
2.2.3 Traditional methods of reform
2.3 Would specialised courts better address the issue of morality?
2.3.1 The US
2.3.2 Europe
2.4 Legislative clarity
2.5 Reform through the patent/intellectual property office
2.6 Ethics committees
2.6.1 National committees
2.6.2 Other committees
2.7 Conclusion
Chapter Three: Decision-Making in Morally Controversial Biotechnological Patent Applications
3.1 Introduction
3.2 Academic calls for more public involvement in biotech patents
3.3 Different ways to facilitate public involvement
3.4 Participation defined
3.4.1 The human right to participate
3.4.2 A United Nations framework for participation
3.4.3 Participation as a reform mechanism?
3.5 Deliberative democracy and its rationale defined
3.5.1 The nature of deliberation: confrontation or comprehending?
3.5.2 Classes of deliberative democracy: elitist or populist?
3.5.3 Early and meaningful input
3.5.4 Deliberative devices and scale Small scale Large scale
3.5.5 Government oversight
3.5.6 Education of the citizenry and inclusion
3.5.7 Location of debate and expert bodies
3.6 Conclusion
Chapter Four: The Participatory Budget in Brazil
4.1 Introduction
4.2 Participatory and representative democracy: some general points
4.2.1 Background to the participatory budget
4.2.2 The participatory budget and how it operates
4.2.3 Increase in scope of issues and political organisation
4.2.4 Obligatory participation or encouragement to participate?
4.2.5 Education and educating the educators
4.2.6 Quasi-legality or legislation?
4.2.7 Effect on civic life of participation
4.2.8 The role of the state in approximating representation to participation
4.2.9 Global recognition and transplantability
4.3 Principles of participation for patent reform
4.4 Conclusion
Chapter Five: Recommendations for Reform and Conclusion
5.1 Introduction
5.2 Proposed structure of a universal patent suffrage at the EPO
5.2.1 Phase one
5.2.2 Phase two
5.2.3 Phase three
5.3 A model for public educating on technology-related issues
5.3.1 Does education about science present specific challenges?
5.3.2 The participatory right in morally controversial patents
5.4 Objections
5.5 Conclusion

Series: Routledge Research in Intellectual Property

Annotated Leading Trademark Cases in Major Asian Jurisdictions
Edited by: Kung-Chung Liu
ISBN 9780367313432
Published October 2019
The Patentability of Software: Software as Mathematics ISBN 9781138240599
Published March 2019
The Patentability of Software: Software as Mathematics (eBook) ISBN 9781315283197
Published March 2019
Contemporary Issues in Pharmaceutical Patent Law ISBN 9780367193386
Published January 2019
Out of print
Intellectual Property, Finance and Corporate Governance ISBN 9781138186255
Published April 2018
Contemporary Issues in Pharmaceutical Patent Law (eBook) ISBN 9781317389781
Published February 2017
Out of print
Contemporary Issues in Pharmaceutical Patent Law ISBN 9781138934481
Published February 2017
Well-Known Trade Marks: A Comparative Study of Japan and the EU ISBN 9781138713338
Published January 2017
Intellectual Property Policy, Law and Administration in Africa ISBN 9781138820739
Published October 2015
A Politics of Patent Law: Crafting the Participatory Patent Bargain ISBN 9780415565172
Published August 2012
Intellectual Property Overlaps: Theory, Strategies, and Solutions ISBN 9780415668163
Published September 2011