Wildy logo
(020) 7242 5778

Wildy’s Book News

Book News cover photo

Vol 23 No 3 March/April 2018

Book of the Month

Cover of Scamell and Gasztowicz on Land Covenants

Scamell and Gasztowicz on Land Covenants

Price: £225.00

Offers for Newly Called Barristers & Students

Special Discounts for Newly Called & Students

Read More ...

Secondhand & Out of Print

Browse Secondhand Online


The Nature and Authority of Precedent

ISBN13: 9780521713368
Published: April 2008
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Country of Publication: UK
Format: Paperback
Price: £30.99

Low stock.

Neil Duxbury examines how precedents constrain legal decision-makers and how legal decision-makers relax and avoid those constraints. There is no single principle or theory which explains the authority of precedent but rather a number of arguments which raise rebuttable presumptions in favour of precedent-following.

This book examines the force and the limitations of these arguments and shows that although the principal requirement of the doctrine of precedent is that courts respect earlier judicial decisions on materially identical facts, the doctrine also requires courts to depart from such decisions when following them would perpetuate legal error or injustice.

Not only do judicial precedents not ‘bind’ judges in the classical-positivist sense, but, were they to do so, they would be ill suited to common-law decision-making. Combining historical inquiry and philosophical analysis, this will assist anyone seeking to understand how precedent operates as a common-law doctrine.

  • The detailed study of a key common-law concept makes this a valuable core law text
  • Written with undergraduate and postgraduate law courses in mind
  • Huge relevance to academic lawyers, barristers and judges within all common-law jurisdictions

English Legal System, Jurisprudence
Part I. Introduction The Usable Past:
1. Precedent
2. Positivism and precedent
3. A theory of precedent?
Part II. Why Does English Law Have a Doctrine of Precedent?:
4. The formation of a doctrine of precedent
Part III. Precedents as Reasons:
5. Looking for a certain ratio
6. Shortcuts to reason
7. Pre-emptive precedent?
8. Conclusion
Part IV. Distinguishing, Overruling and the Problem of Self-Reference:
9. Distinguishing
10. Overruling
11. The power to overrule oneself
12. The authority of the Practice Statement
Part V. Why Follow Precedent?:
13. Consequentialist justifications
14. Deontological arguments
15. Conclusion.