Wildy logo
(020) 7242 5778

Wildy’s Book News

Book News cover photo

Vol 21 No 9 Sept/Oct 2016

Book of the Month

Cover of Goode on Commercial Law

Goode on Commercial Law

Edited by: Ewan McKendrick
Price: £170.00

Pupillage & Student Offers

Special Discounts for Pupils, Newly Called & Students

Read More ...

Secondhand & Out of Print

Browse Secondhand Online


Facing Judicial Discretion

Image not available lge
Marisa Iglesias VilaDepartment of Legal, Moral and Political Philosophy, Pompeu Fabra University, Barcelona, Spain

ISBN13: 9780792367789
ISBN: 0792367782
Published: January 2001
Publisher: Kluwer Law International
Format: Hardback
Price: Out of print

This volume addresses the classical but nonetheless still controversial question of what the role is of judicial discretion in adjudication. Its main purpose is to discuss the philosophical and epistemic foundations of two different legal theories: Hartian positivism and Dworkin's interpretivism. Bearing in mind the debate between realism and antirealism, the author shows how Hartian positivism faces serious difficulties to avoid global scepticism, and the problem of rule-following by simply connecting legal determinacy with the existence of settled conventions. In contrast, it is argued that Dworkin's interpretive theory can overcome scepticism by connecting legal determinacy with the idea of the best interpretation, and by rejecting externalism. With a view to justifying this claim, the author presents a reconstruction of Dworkin's philosophical position, which developed along the lines of Putnam's internal realism and Rawls' reflective equilibrium. This book should be of interest to legal theorists, lawyers, judges, and philosophers.

Image not available lge
Acknowledgements. Introduction. I. The Concept of Judicial Discretion. II. The Strong Discretion Model. III. The Weak Discretion Model. IV. Interpretation versus Invention. V. Coherence in Legal Interpretation. VI. Hard Cases and Legal Determinacy. Bibliography. Index.